1. - General remarks
Disasters, whether natural, technological or man-made, are unfortunately a fact
of life. One aspect common to them all is the inevitability of the many police,
technical, medical and other investigations that follow. The purpose of this Interpol
guide is to promulgate good practice in respect of one type of investigation conducted
when lives have been lost: Disaster Victim Identification.
While this document is based on practical experience gained from actual incidents,
it is recognized that the guidelines may need to be adapted by member countries
to conform to national or regional laws and regulations, or to religious or
organizational practices.
Disaster victim identification, normally the responsibility of the police,
is a difficult and demanding exercise which can only be brought to a successful
conclusion if properly planned and which, of necessity, has to involve the active
participation of many other agencies. It is, however, only one aspect of dealing
with disasters which will always vary considerably in scale and effect. Nevertheless,
the identification procedures described in this guide can be used in all circumstances,
irrespective of the number of victims involved. The ultimate aim of all disaster
victim identification operations must invariably be to establish the identity
of every victim by comparing and matching accurate ante-mortem (AM) and post-mortem
(PM) data.
Chapter 2 refers briefly to some of the general
aspects of disaster handling in order to illustrate the way in which the many
operations to be undertaken interact, and the need for co-ordination and interaction
between them.
Chapter 3 briefly explains identification methods
and the reasons for involving several groups of specialists in an integrated
operation.
Chapter 4 describes the three major stages in victim
identification, namely:
- procurement of ante-mortem information for possible victims (AM data)
-
recovery and examination of bodies to establish reliable post-mortem evidence
from the deceased (PM data)
-
comparison of AM and PM data to identify each body.
Chapter 5 refers to a series of elimination tables
which can be used to facilitate a manual data-matching process.
Each member country will have to decide whether or not to use this system or
an alternative method such as a computer application.
Liaison between member countries after a disaster or when planning the response
to one, aspects of international law, regulations, agreements and conventions
and are dealt with in Chapter 6 and the Appendices.
Appendix D, in particular, gives the Interpol
resolution on disaster victim identification which was adopted by the General
Assembly at its 65th session, held in 1996.
| 1.2
- Disaster Victim Identification Commissions |
|
|
In order to achieve, maintain and improve standards, and facilitate international
liaison, Interpol recommends that each member country establish one or more permanent
Disaster Victim Identification Commissions. They should have a responsibility
not only for disaster response, but also for the vital functions of pre-planning
and training of key personnel who may by virtue of their position suddenly become
involved in, or responsible for, one or more of the many aspects of a disaster
including victim identification.
The identification procedures described later in this Guide assume that post-disaster
intervention will be organized; they are intended to serve as a sound basis
upon which to develop disaster victim identification practices and standardize
them in many respects. The advice may be of particular help to member countries
which do not have permanent Disaster Victim Identification Commissions.
The Interpol Standing Committee on Disaster Victim Identification has developed
and refined internationally agreed Disaster Victim Identification Forms which
could, in fact, also be used in cases involving a single unidentified body. Use
of these forms by all member countries will ensure that comprehensive information
is obtained and will also greatly facilitate the transmission of identification
data between member countries. The AM and PM data-recording processes described
are based on the use of these forms. The forms themselves, with explanatory notes
on how to fill them in, are published separately by the Interpol General Secretariat.
It is important that whenever a country introduces forms for its own internal
use, the coding system of the internationally approved Interpol forms be strictly
respected.
| 1.4
- Religion and culture |
|
|
Religious and cultural customs differ considerably throughout the world and this
fact must be taken into account when planning the response to disaster scenarios.
Experience proves that this factor is of particular relevance when dealing with
survivors, relatives and the remains of the victims.
Each religious faith and ethnic culture has its own ethical considerations when
dealing with the dead and dying. It is not possible to list the requirements and
expectations of each individual denomination or persuasion in this Guide, but
the importance of sensitivity and understanding when dealing with all victims
should never be overlooked.
Nevertheless, religious and cultural considerations, however important in their
own right, cannot be allowed to compromise the legal processes to which local
authorities and investigating agencies may be bound by law.
When planning for disasters, member countries are advised to find out about
the needs and wishes of the various faiths. It will then be possible to ascertain
the type of assistance that may be available, both for investigators and for
the families of victims, from the representatives of those faiths. Such prior
understanding will undoubtedly help to avoid conflict between the official agencies
and others involved in the aftermath.
Member countries are also advised to try to establish multi-agency 'faith
community teams' to be called upon for advice and support during times
of crisis. Such teams have proved to be of great help in previous incidents
and have provided valuable assistance to the injured, bereaved and distressed,
as well as to official agencies.
Faith community teams can assist by:
- tending to the dead and injured
-
accompanying those required to view bodies
-
providing spiritual comfort to survivors, evacuees, families, etc.
-
providing advice on religious requirements.
| 1.5
- Stress and welfare of personnel |
|
|
Stress is a normal reaction to an abnormal situation. The importance of being
able to recognize and deal with its effects should not be under-estimated. Everyone
involved in a disaster will suffer a degree of stress, but for some this can develop
from a normal reaction into a medical disorder with potentially serious physical
and psychological consequences.
The greatest risk comes when confronting the abnormal, unfamiliar and sometimes
almost overwhelming circumstances inherent in disasters. Dealing with the deceased,
survivors and relatives contributes to the unusual and often unexpected pressures
on the individual required to respond. It is recommended that contingency plans
include provisions to counter the effects of stress on personnel.
Methods of reducing the effects of stress are well researched and documented,
and it is not possible to go into detail in this Guide. In summary, proper briefing
and preparation of staff is vital and can best be achieved by suitable training
for the tasks they will be expected to perform. Of equal importance is debriefing
at the conclusion of the incident or when staff are withdrawn from the operation,
not only to review the professional aspects but also to provide an opportunity
to discuss personal feelings and reactions. This can be conducted individually
or by team, but in each case critical incident stress debriefing must be considered
as of benefit to the individual. Most disasters have revealed a need for long-term
counselling for some people. To be effective, both counselling and critical
incident stress debriefing should be conducted by properly trained staff and
be seen as a confidential, and often essential, medical service.
During the searching and identification stages a suitable diet can assist in
reducing stress. There is a wide range of other helpful techniques such as regular
breaks, personnel rotation, gentle exercises, etc., but clearly the choice of
methods will depend on the circumstances and must be left to supervisors.
| 1.6
- Equipment and personnel |
|
|
It is obviously impossible for this Guide to provide an exhaustive list of the
equipment needed to deal with all aspects of all disasters.
Requirements will vary, depending on the type of incident (air crash, earthquake,
flooding, chemical release), the location (city centre, desert, mountainous
area, at sea) the weather (snow, extreme temperatures, monsoon), on the type
of personnel being or likely to be used (police, military, volunteers) and on
the equipment already available to such personnel in the normal course of their
duties.
There are, however, some items which are always needed in certain contexts.
A list is given below.
The scene of the incident
- body bags
- body labels
- property bags
- property labels
- body and property stakes
- site demarcation tape or barriers
- stretchers
- ground-clearing equipment
- search and detection equipment
- identification badges/clothing
- maps / aerial photographs
- draughtsmans materials
- photographic equipment
The mortuary
- examination tables
- body storage facilities
- heating/cooling units
- specialist examination instruments
- specimen storage containers
- drainage
- waste disposal
- X-ray machines
- photographic equipment
- fingerprint equipment
Transport
- of bodies from scene, within mortuary, etc.: refrigerated trucks
- of personnel to and from scene
- of evacuees and casualties
- of equipment and ID data files
- for debris/evidence removal
- tow trucks
- recovery vehicles
Administration
- premises
- furniture
- Interpol forms
- other stationery
- weatherproof pens/pencils
- files
- cabinets
- first-aid and medical equipment
- petty cash ad hoc expenses and purchases
Communications
- radio
- telephone
- facsimile
- computer
- photocopiers
- dispatch service
- management information service
- briefing material
Power supplies
- scene
- mortuary
- temporary buildings
Welfare
- washing facilities
- food and drink
- personal protective clothing
- advice/counselling service
It will be appreciated that no list can be exhaustive, and any attempt to
devise and publish a complete inventory of recommended equipment would not only
be futile, but might lead to a false sense of security.
However, many Interpol member countries have drawn up plans and acquired equipment
which suits the perceived needs of their particular areas of operation. Their
experience will be made available to other countries requesting information
either directly or via the Interpol General Secretariat.
Similarly, no definitive guidance can be given on the number of people likely
to be required to respond to and deal with a disaster. Again, the type and location
of the incident as well as numerous other criteria will need to be taken into
account.
One particular piece of advice can, however, be given. Those who have had to
deal with disasters on whatever scale will always agree that it is very easy
to underestimate the time, number of staff, and amount of equipment that will
be required.
| Disaster Victim
Identification |
|